Elektrine lite

← Feed

@XiJinpingStanAccount@lemmy.ml

2026-11-12 08:35 UTC

Value comes from labor. That value is tied to the specific thing being made. Even if your initial creation of the software is difficult the fact that it can be copied for no cost dilutes that labor value down to nothing. A new copy does not take money away from you. It does not steal your labor value. That is the anti-piracy argument and it is empircally false. As I said you are welcome to do a donationware model and still have it be entirely moral and I’m sure that you’d get more than your labors typical market value back. But what you want to be able to do is to withhold the code and not allow it to be copied without paying. So that you can extract infinite value from something that cost a finite amount to create initially and now costs nothing to copy. That is exploitative.

Replies (2)

  • @hperrin@lemmy.ca 2026-11-12 14:37

    You’ve clearly never asked for donations for an open source project. I have. The vast majority of open source projects get no donations. Most of the rest get a small amount per month. Not enough to survive on. A handful get a lot of donations. One of my libraries is used by about 3,800 other projects. It was actually the first popular UI library for the Svelte framework. I’ve not gotten one single donation for it. It has a donation page, and no one has ever taken me up on it. I’ve put hundreds (maybe thousands) of hours of work into that project since I started it in 2017. The only reason I was able to build it is that I also get paid to write proprietary software. Most of the big, popular open source projects also only exist because of proprietary software. They get patches from the companies who use them. That’s why I am telling you that what you’re advocating for could only work in a planned economy. I’m not going to work for free if I can’t afford to eat. The argument for piracy was never about money. It was about ownership. I’m sorry that the reason you pirate is because you don’t want to financially support the artists. That’s very shameful. The reason I pirate is because after I’ve purchased some media, I want to own it. So let me ask you this: can you list out all of the open source projects you’ve used, and how much you’ve donated to each one?

    Open ##5523986

  • @hperrin@lemmy.ca 2026-11-12 15:36

    Honestly, it’s people like you, who feel entitled to my labor, who make me feel like it’s a mistake to release anything I make as open source.

    Open ##5524227